Homemade Oatmeal Cream Pies Recipe

If you’ve ever craved that nostalgic, sweet, and chewy treat that transports you straight back to your childhood, then this Homemade Oatmeal Cream Pies Recipe is just what you need. Nothing beats the warm comfort of soft oatmeal cookies sandwiched with a luscious cream cheese filling — I swear every time I make these, the house smells like a cozy hug. Plus, they’re perfect for cozy afternoons, lunchboxes, or just because you deserve a little indulgence.

I love how this Homemade Oatmeal Cream Pies Recipe strikes the perfect balance between old-fashioned charm and simple, reliable ingredients. You’ll enjoy how straightforward the process is, even if you’re not baking every weekend. The combination of molasses and cinnamon in the cookies gives them that irresistible depth, while the creamy filling adds a smooth finishing touch that keeps everyone coming back for more.

Ingredients You’ll Need

Each ingredient in this Homemade Oatmeal Cream Pies Recipe plays its part in creating that classic chewy texture and mouthwatering flavor. When you shop, look for quality butter and full-fat cream cheese to make sure your filling is silky, and choose quick oats for that tender cookie bite.

• Unsalted butter: Using unsalted gives you control over sodium, and softened butter blends better into the dough and filling.
• Brown sugar: Adds moisture and a rich, caramel-like depth that complements the molasses perfectly.
• Granulated sugar: Balances sweetness and helps create a perfect cookie texture.
• Molasses: This is the secret to that signature oatmeal cream pie flavor—don’t skip it!
• Vanilla extract: A splash enhances all the other flavors without overpowering.
• Large eggs: They’re your binder, making sure it all comes together nicely.
• All-purpose flour: Easy to find and gives the right structure to your cookies.
• Cinnamon: Just a pinch adds warmth and cozy spice.
• Baking soda: Helps the cookies rise just the right amount for that chewy softness.
• Salt: Balances the sweetness and intensifies the other flavors.
• Quick oats: These oats give the cookie that classic chewy bite without being too hard or rustic.
• Cream cheese (full-fat, brick style): The cream filling’s star—full-fat for richness and stability.
• Powdered sugar: For a silky smooth sweet cream filling.
• Cream (optional): Just a tablespoon helps fine-tune the frosting’s consistency if needed.

Variations

I always encourage personalizing this Homemade Oatmeal Cream Pies Recipe if you want to add your own twist or cater to dietary needs. It’s a forgiving recipe, so you can experiment confidently.

• Gluten-free version: I swapped in a gluten-free flour blend once, and the texture was surprisingly close to the original. Just make sure your baking soda is gluten-free too!
• Maple flavor: I sometimes replace molasses with maple syrup for a sweeter, lighter topping that’s perfect for autumn vibes.
• Vegan option: Try using vegan butter and egg replacer, plus a vegan cream cheese. I haven’t perfected it yet, but it’s pretty darn close and feels great as a plant-based treat.
• Extra chewy oats: If you want a bit more oat texture, use half rolled oats and half quick oats—adds a nice rustic bite.

How to Make Homemade Oatmeal Cream Pies Recipe

Step 1: Cream your butter and sugars until fluffy

Start by beating the softened butter together with the brown and granulated sugars. I like to go for about 3-5 minutes until the mixture turns light and fluffy, which really helps the cookies have a soft texture. This step is worth the little patience — you’ll feel the difference in the final cookie softness.

Step 2: Add in the molasses, vanilla, and eggs

Next, mix in the molasses and vanilla extract. It gives that deep, classic flavor. Then add the eggs one at a time, beating well after each addition so you get a smooth and creamy base—no lumpy batter here!

Step 3: Combine dry ingredients and fold in oats

Turn off your mixer, then add the flour, cinnamon, baking soda, and salt. It’s best to start mixing by hand a bit to keep flour from dusting everywhere. Once mostly combined, turn the mixer on low to finish it off. Then fold in your quick oats with a spatula. The oats bring in that comforting texture we all remember.

Step 4: Scoop and bake the cookies

I find using a cookie scoop helps keep the sizes consistent and promises even baking. Make balls about 1 to 1.5 tablespoons each and place them spaced 2 inches apart on your lined baking sheet. Bake at 350°F (180°C) for around 9 to 11 minutes, checking that the tops look set but still soft—you don’t want them to brown too much.

Step 5: Make the cream cheese filling

While your cookies cool, whip up the filling by beating the softened butter until fluffy. Then beat in chopped cream cheese pieces until smooth. Add powdered sugar a bit at a time, starting low and increasing speed so your mixer doesn’t puff sugar clouds everywhere. If the filling feels a bit dense, a tablespoon of cream loosens it right up without losing structure.

Step 6: Assemble your oatmeal cream pies

Once cookies are completely cooled—this is key!—spread about 1 to 1.5 tablespoons of cream filling on the bottom of one cookie, then gently press a second cookie on top, flat side facing down. This creates that perfect sandwich that holds together but still melts in your mouth.

How to Serve Homemade Oatmeal Cream Pies Recipe

Garnishes

I usually keep it simple here—no fancy toppings. Just a light dusting of powdered sugar adds that extra touch of sweetness and makes them look inviting on the plate. For a special touch, sometimes I like a thin drizzle of melted chocolate on top, especially if I’m serving these at a party.

Side Dishes

Pair these with a cold glass of milk or a hot cup of tea (Earl Grey is my favorite) for a cozy snack. They’re also wonderful alongside fresh fruit or a simple fruit compote if you want a contrast to the rich cream filling.

Creative Ways to Present

For birthdays or holiday parties, I’ve arranged them on tiered dessert trays, decorated with little edible flowers or fresh herbs like mint for a pop of color. You can also wrap individual pies in parchment paper tied with twine to make them charming homemade gifts—everyone loves receiving these!

Make Ahead and Storage

Storing Leftovers

I keep leftover oatmeal cream pies in an airtight container in the refrigerator. They stay fresh and soft for up to 5 days. Just make sure to separate layers with parchment paper to prevent sticking. I’ve found they actually taste even better after a day as the flavors meld beautifully.

Freezing

If you want to make these ahead of time, freeze them assembled on a baking sheet, then transfer to a freezer-safe bag once firm. I’ve frozen them for up to 3 months—just thaw in the fridge overnight before serving. This is a lifesaver for busy weeks or unexpected guests!

Reheating

Reheating isn’t usually necessary, but if you prefer a slightly warm oatmeal cream pie, I zap it in the microwave for just 10-15 seconds—enough to soften the cream without melting it completely. Soft and delicious, every time.

FAQs

Final Thoughts

This Homemade Oatmeal Cream Pies Recipe is one of those treats that’s truly worth the little effort because it brings such joy — whether you’re making them for your family, friends, or a cozy night in. I’ve shared these at gatherings and watched them disappear faster than I could snap a photo. Give this recipe a go and enjoy those sweet moments of baking and sharing, knowing you’ve created a classic with your own hands.

Print